CELTIC FC

SFA Admit Celtic’s Motherwell Penalty Should Never Have Stood as VAR Controversy Reignites Debate

Published

34 seconds ago

May 25, 2026

Fresh controversy has erupted around Celtic F.C. after the Scottish Football Association reportedly confirmed that the dramatic late penalty awarded against Motherwell F.C. should never have been given, sparking renewed criticism of VAR decision-making in Scottish football.

The incident, which occurred during Celtic’s tense clash with Motherwell, became one of the season’s most talked-about moments after a late handball decision changed the course of the match. Referee John Beaton initially waved play on before intervention from VAR led to an on-field review and the eventual awarding of a penalty. The spot-kick proved decisive, helping Celtic stay firmly in the title race at a crucial stage of the campaign.

However, the SFA’s Key Match Incident (KMI) panel later reviewed the flashpoint and reportedly concluded that the original on-field decision should have remained unchanged. According to the findings, the majority of panel members believed VAR was wrong to intervene and that the penalty should not have been awarded in the first place.

The decision has fueled intense debate among supporters, pundits, and former players, with some describing the call as one of the most controversial VAR moments seen in Scottish football in recent years. Critics argue the incident once again highlights concerns over consistency and interpretation of handball decisions, while others believe the growing influence of VAR is damaging trust in officiating.

Despite the fallout, Celtic ultimately pushed on in their campaign, but the controversy surrounding the Motherwell penalty remains a major talking point. With officiating decisions continuing to come under scrutiny, pressure is mounting on football authorities to provide greater clarity and consistency in the use of VAR across the Scottish game.

CELTIC FC

Robbie Keane Breaks Silence on Celtic Manager Rumours as £10M Transfer Twist Sparks Fresh Speculation

Published

13 hours ago

May 24, 2026

90minsoccer

Speculation surrounding a possible return to Celtic for former striker and current coach Robbie Keane has intensified after fresh reports linked him with the managerial position at the Scottish giants. With uncertainty still surrounding the club’s long-term leadership plans, Keane’s name continues to dominate conversations among supporters and pundits alike.

The former Republic of Ireland captain, who previously enjoyed a memorable spell at Celtic during his playing days, has recently spoken about the growing speculation over his future. Despite being heavily linked with the managerial vacancy, Keane appeared measured in his response, refusing to be drawn too deeply into rumours while acknowledging the attention surrounding his name. Reports suggest he remains one of the leading candidates under consideration as Celtic weigh up their next move.

Keane’s reputation as a manager has grown steadily following his time with Hungarian side Ferencváros, where he guided the club to domestic silverware and gained valuable European experience. However, his recent departure from the club has only fuelled speculation that a major move could now be on the horizon, with Celtic supporters closely watching developments.

Adding another layer of intrigue is a reported £10 million transfer situation that could shape Celtic’s summer plans. The transfer twist has raised fresh questions over what direction the club intends to take and whether a new manager—potentially Keane—could influence incoming business in the market. While no official decision has been announced, the timing of recent developments has intensified excitement and debate around the club’s future.

For now, nothing has been confirmed, but Keane’s growing links with Celtic continue to gather momentum. Whether he ultimately returns to the club in the dugout or chooses another opportunity, the coming weeks could prove decisive in shaping the next chapter for both manager and club.